Handcrafted Cheese

Not all cheeses are made the same, which is why it’s essential to choose your cheese carefully, paying particular attention to the milk it is made with. Raw milk cheese provides the flavor you expect without the preservatives or GMOs. At The Old Dutch Cupboard, we provide handcrafted, raw milk cheeses made from the milk of grass-fed cows and goats. We sell the finest cheeses from top local brands, including:

John F. Martin & Sons Cheese

In addition to their farm-fresh meats, John F. Martin & Sons are known for their high-end cheeses made with milk sourced from small family farms in Pennsylvania. Families of all ages enjoy their sliced American cheese and cream cheese dips as their mid-afternoon snacks and additions to their family dinners. Choose only the best for your dishes, and shop at The Old Dutch Cupboard for your favorite specialty cheeses, including raw cheese, flavored cheddar and Swiss cheeses, and cream cheese dips. We have everything you need to create an unbelievably delicious snack, appetizer, side dish, or entree.

Swiss Villa Raw Milk Cheese

Raw milk cheeses come in various forms, including firm, creamy, and crumbly, and are made by small-scale artisanal producers. They are highly praised for their rich and complex flavors and aromatics. Complete your charcuterie board or top off your sandwich with Swiss Villa Raw Milk Cheese. You can find these handcrafted goat and cow cheeses in our store today.

September Farms Cheese

Life is better with cheese, especially when it’s September Farms Cheese. Take your burgers, sandwiches, dishes, and cheese-and-crackers snacks to a whole new level with aged cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, or bold Monterey Jack cheese. Enjoy a variety of flavors, including Honey Brook Sharp Cheddar and Pepperoni Augusto Jack, for something new every day.

Snowville Creamery Cheese

More and more people are finding it difficult to digest milk and milk-based products, and this is often due to the protein called A1 found in regular milk. Raw milk contains A2 protein that is much easier to digest. Treat your stomach kindly and choose A2 Raw Milk White Cheddar from Snowville Creamery. The cheese is made with milk from grass-fed cows and does not contain any GMOs. When you eat Snowville Creamery cheese, the rich flavor is unmistakable.